WebAug 28, 2024 · If Patel applies to tort law, it arguably overrules sub silentio decisions in the law of torts that lay down an alternative approach. More particularly, it would conceivably follow that Patel overturns the momentous decision of the House of Lords in Gray v Thames Trains [2009], in which a causal test was embraced. WebGray v Thames Trains [2009] - Background. Facts: C suffers PTSD as a result of D's negligence. C kills a pedestrian while suffering with PTSD. C seeks compensation for loss of earnings and general harm resulting from manslaughter conviction
UK: Why Is The "illegality" Defence Back In The Spotlight?
WebJul 6, 2007 · 1. The Claimant in this case, Mr Kerrie Gray, who is now aged 47, was one of the victims of the Ladbroke Grove rail crash which occurred on 5 October 1999. He … WebGray v Thames Trains Ltd – Case Summary Gray v Thames Trains Ltd House of Lords Citations: [2009] UKHL 33; [2009] 1 AC 1339; [2009] 3 WLR 167; [2009] 4 All ER 81; … the barley house seacoast
Judgments - Gray (Original Respondent and Cross appellants) v Thames ...
WebFeb 2, 2024 · Mr Gray’s liability to compensate the dependants of the dead pedestrian was an immediate “inextricable” consequence of his having intentionally killed him. The same is true of his feelings of guilt and remorse. I therefore think that Flaux J was right and I would allow the appeal and restore his judgment. WebApr 24, 2013 · Gray v Thames Trains [2009] UKHL 33 Facts: The claimant was severely injured in a train crash caused by the defendant's negligence. Subsequently the claimant suffered a mental breakdown and killed another person. The claimant was detained and sought damages from the defendant for loss of earnings. WebOct 6, 2024 · But in doing so, it also re-introduced ideas from the earlier case of Gray v Thames Trains Ltd. Footnote 30 Indeed, a significant amount of the judgment was given over to the questions of whether Gray could be distinguished (the answer was no), Footnote 31 and whether the approach in Gray was compatible with the approach in Patel (the … the gunlock falls